GET UP TO 66% OFF + FREE SHIPPING
Advertorial
Home > Trending > Food & Drink
This Is How 99% Of Coffee Capsules Are Made. It Explains The Watery Taste
And why one Northern Italian roastery refused to do it that way.
As Seen On Sponsored Content
December 11th, 2025 | 12:20 am EST
Sofia Romano, Food & Lifestyle Writer
I wasn't supposed to care this much about capsule coffee.
My editor asked me to test 20 compatible pods for a "best Nespresso alternatives" roundup.
Standard assignment. Taste them, rank them, write it up.
This isn't that article.
Because somewhere around pod #12, I started getting annoyed.
And by pod #20, I wasn't just annoyed.
I was angry.
Not because they were bad in different ways.
Because they were bad in exactly the same way.
Same flat aroma. Same hollow body. Same stale, slightly metallic finish - like the beans had been sitting somewhere too long.
Different brands. Different prices. Different packaging.
Same thin, watery extraction. Same crema that vanished in seconds.
I was tasting €0.35 pods and €0.95 pods side by side - and I couldn’t reliably tell the difference.
That’s when I stopped writing the roundup.
Because if you drink 2-3 cups a day, you already know this adds up.
Even at €0.70-€0.85 per pod, that’s €765-€930 a year.
Almost a thousand euros.
For something that disappoints you before 7am.
And millions of people were paying it. Every single morning.
How The Industry Actually Works
I wanted to understand WHY they all tasted the same.
Different companies. Different countries. Different price points.
Same result.
So I started making calls. Roasters. Packaging suppliers. I even tracked down a former quality manager at one of Europe's largest capsule contractors.
He agreed to talk, off the record.
"The spec sheet tells you everything," he said. "Shelf life: 18-24 months. Oxygen limits. Moisture limits. Logistics limits. Flavor isn’t on that page."
And a pattern emerged.
The problem isn't the capsule technology.
The problem is what happens BEFORE the coffee goes into the capsule.
Three Problems With Most Coffee Pods
Most brands - including premium ones - design their product around:
Mass production speed
Shelf stability (months in warehouses)
Retail margins
Brand positioning
In order to hit all the boxes, they tend to:
❌ Over-Roast to Fake Intensity
Brands use cheap commodity beans, then roast them dark to create the illusion of "strength."
This burns off all the nuance and complexity.
You get bitterness, but not richness.
One roaster told me: "Intensity 10 usually just means we burnt it more."
❌ Use Wrong Extraction Engineering
The capsule design restricts water flow during brewing.
Water moves too fast through the coffee bed.
Oils don't emulsify properly.
Crema collapses immediately.
❌ The "Brand Tax"
Premium brands charge €0.70-€1.00 per capsule.
But you're not paying for better coffee.
You're paying for:
Retail store overhead
Massive advertising budgets (those George Clooney ads aren't free)
Celebrity endorsements
Premium packaging
Brand positioning
The coffee itself? That's almost an afterthought.
I Almost Killed The Story
At this point, I had an article that basically said: "They're all mediocre. Save your money."
Not exactly what my editor wanted.
So I kept digging. Looking for the exception.
Were there any small roasteries - the kind that supply actual Italian cafés - making capsules?
Places where the roastmaster still tastes every batch?
Where "intensity" means flavor complexity, not burnt bitterness?
Most didn't do capsules. They saw it as beneath them. A compromise they refused to make.
But I kept asking.
Then I Found One That Did It Differently
A contact in Milan mentioned a roastery in Northern Italy.
Third-generation family operation. Supplying cafés since 1962.
They'd spent years saying no to capsule partnerships — until they found a way to do it without compromising.
They'd partnered with a Swedish company called Coffydoor to bring their coffee direct-to-consumer. In capsule form. But on their terms.
No shortcuts. No commodity beans. No over-roasting.
The same coffee they'd stake their reputation on in a café - just in a different format.
I was skeptical. But I'd tested 20 disappointing pods already. What was one more?
So I ordered a box.
I Knew Before I Even Tasted It
I noticed it the moment it started extracting.
Not that dull, stale “coffee-ish” smell I’d gotten used to with pods.
This filled the kitchen like a cafe. Warm. Roasted. Alive.
I brewed the Ristretto.
The crema came through thick. Golden-brown. And it held.
Then I tasted it.
Depth. Chocolate. A hint of fruit. Clean finish.
No bitterness.
No hollow aftertaste.
I just sat there for a second, annoyed for a different reason.
Where the hell was this for the first 20 pods?
What They Refused To Compromise On
If you do a quick Google search, you’ll find their street tastings.
People taking a sip and doing the same little pause I did.
Eyebrows up.
“Wait… that’s a pod?”
Yeah.
Then I checked reviews.
On Trustpilot they’re sitting at 4.8/5 across 1,752 reviews - and the comments are weirdly consistent: crema, body, aroma, “finally.”
So how is it possible?
The difference
It comes down to a few non-negotiables:
✓ Better Beans The same sourcing they use for their cafe clients. Not industrial commodity lots.
✓ Italian Roasting Craft Roasted by people who grew up with espresso. Not optimized for shelf life.
✓ Proper Extraction Engineering Capsules designed for correct water flow. Oils emulsify. Crema holds.
✓ Direct-to-Door Pricing No retail markup. No “brand tax.” Fresh coffee shipped straight to you.
So that’s the real difference.
Most pods are built for warehouses and margins. Coffydoor is built for taste first - and then engineered to work inside a Nespresso machine.
How to try it
Coffydoor sells direct. No retail, no middlemen.
Most people start with the Starter Kit - 120 capsules across all three blends, plus a thermos mug and storage tin.
Right now there's a 60% holiday discount for new customers. Ships free.
If you don't love it, there's a 60-day guarantee. Full refund, no questions.
You can also pause, skip, or cancel the subscription anytime - no hoops.
Verified Purchase
This coffee is hands down the best Nespresso-compatible choice!
It’s far better than Nespresso’s own collection — the crema and aroma are simply unmatched. My whole family uses Coffydoor, and my mum is especially happy with their new decaf option. Highly recommended!
JB
Jesper B
Verified Purchase
I switched to coffee pods a year ago for convenience, but I was afraid the taste wouldn't be the same as coffee beans...
After a year of trying mainstream brands, I didn't find anything better than mediocre tasting.
I received my first Coffydoor box yesterday, and was excited to try it.
I can confidently say that their pods beat every single mainstream brand I've tried, and I won't be looking elsewhere.
Thank you for this experience!
MS
Martin S
Verified Purchase
Truly great coffee. Every sip reminds me of the cafes of naples.
Espresso and Lungo are the best as they are medium roast, ristretto is a litte bit strong for my taste buds.
You guys are doing a great job in delivering great quality coffee.
Recommended
4.8 | 1,752 Reviews
Holiday Kit: 120 Capsules + Premium Extras
120 hand-roasted Italian capsules
Matte black thermos mug (350ml, leak-proof, keeps coffee hot for hours)
Scandinavian-designed storage tin (holds 40 capsules, looks stunning on your counter)
Free home delivery
Check Availability